This is hands down one of our favorite summer dishes. We look forward to it and lust after it all winter and spring long. It’s so delicious that it’s like our reward for making it through the doldrums of winter. Yes, we could certainly gather these ingredients and making it any time we wanted, but it would be cheating ourselves. There is just nothing else that compares to the sweet ripe taste of a fresh tomato (especially if it’s grown by you or someone you know) in the summertime. We are fortunate enough to get fresh off the vine tomatoes from my grandfather’s garden throughout the summer, so we take full advantage of all of the wonderful summer dishes and recipes they lend themselves to. Tomato pie being one of the best.
It sounds a bit strange… do you eat it hot? Is it saucy? Is it time consuming like those crazy apple pies with the lattice top can be? Well folks, luckily this is one of the easiest dishes in the book (on the blog). I will admit that we cut a corner and buy an already prepared, frozen pie crust – but if you made a homemade one I bet it would blow our version out of the water. So we baked the crust for about 10 minutes after pricking it just to let it turn golden. Then it’s just a matter of layering. We start with a layer of spinach (helps soak up some of the juice, minimizing soggyness), then a thin layer of sliced red onion, fresh garlic and basil, and then layers upon layers (until you reach the top of the crust) of sliced tomatoes. We’ve learned over time that the trick is to let the sliced tomatoes sit in a colander with a little salt sprinkled on them for about 10 minutes to release some of their moisture. Then pat them dry with a paper towel. Of course the pie was still delicious before this trick dawned on us, just a bit more messy.
The best part of the pie (after the tomatoes) is the topping. It’s a mixture of shredded parmesan, cheddar, and mozzarella with enough mayo to make it spreadable. Then you just smear that over the top – and if you REALLY want to go nuts, add a little crumbled bacon (wow), plus a little oregano and basil. Bake it for about 20-30 minutes or until the cheese is golden and bubbly, and then get ready to eat one of the best summer meals of your life.